Why Merchant Revenue Is Treated as Uncertain by Lenders
Lenders do not model merchant electricity revenue at spot price forecasts.
They apply haircuts — conservative discounts to projected market prices —
that reflect the possibility that prices will be lower than forecast during
the debt repayment period. The size of those haircuts depends on the market,
the project type, and the lender's own risk appetite, but they are
consistently applied. A project that looks adequately covered at forecast
spot prices may fall below the required debt service coverage ratio once
those haircuts are applied. Sponsors who build their financing case on
merchant revenue projections without stress-testing against lender haircut
assumptions frequently discover the gap between their model and the
bank's model during due diligence, at which point the options for
closing that gap are limited and expensive.
How a Power Purchase Agreement Reframes the Risk
A power purchase agreement is the standard offtake instrument in the
electricity sector. When a renewable energy project signs a long-term power
purchase agreement with a creditworthy buyer — a utility, a large commercial
or industrial consumer, or a government entity — the contracted price
replaces market price uncertainty for the volumes covered. Lenders can model
the contracted revenue with much higher confidence than merchant revenue,
and the debt service coverage ratio is calculated against that contracted
floor rather than a discounted forecast of spot prices. The transformation
is structural: the project's exposure to electricity market volatility
is reduced to the volumes and periods not covered by the agreement. Lenders
assess the residual merchant exposure separately and size the debt
accordingly. The practical effect is that a well-structured power purchase
agreement allows the project to carry more debt at lower cost than an
equivalent uncontracted project.
The Role of Contract for Difference Structures in Australian Renewable
Finance
In addition to traditional power purchase agreements, Australian renewable
energy projects increasingly use contract for difference structures, where
the project sells electricity into the spot market but receives a payment
from the counterparty when the spot price falls below a contracted strike
price, and pays the counterparty when the spot price exceeds it. From a
financing perspective, a contract for difference provides a revenue floor —
the strike price — that lenders can rely on for debt service modelling
purposes, while allowing the project to capture upside when spot prices are
high. Lenders assess these structures by examining the creditworthiness of
the counterparty providing the floor payment, the duration of the contract
relative to the debt tenor, and whether the strike price is set at a level
that covers debt service under the lender's conservative revenue
assumptions. The mechanics differ from a traditional power purchase
agreement, but the financing logic is the same: convert price uncertainty
into counterparty risk.
Volume Risk in Renewable Energy: Why Capacity Factor Matters
Unlike industrial projects that produce a fixed output from a controlled
process, renewable energy projects generate electricity at a rate determined
by weather conditions. A solar farm produces less in cloudy periods; a wind
farm produces less in low-wind seasons. Lenders account for this by
modelling revenue against a conservative capacity factor — typically the P90
generation estimate, meaning the output level that is expected to be
achieved or exceeded ninety percent of the time based on long-term resource
data. The offtake agreement interacts with this variability: a take-or-pay
structure that commits the buyer to pay for a fixed energy volume regardless
of actual generation creates a problem if the project cannot consistently
deliver that volume. Most renewable energy power purchase agreements are
structured on a take-and-pay basis for actual generation, with the
contracted price applying to whatever volume is delivered. Lenders then
model revenue as the contracted price multiplied by the P90 generation
estimate — a conservative but defensible revenue floor.